One for All the Math Geniuses
Moderators: piaptk, tragwag, Steve E., Aussie0zborn
One for All the Math Geniuses
Guy I know is an amateur filmmaker.
The scene he's shooting involves a depressed man who walks into his apartment and the Mama Cass record he started when he left earlier is still playing - and sticking in the groove.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSu_irpykNo
No-one else
Will ever love you
plays over and over and over until he shoots himself in the head - whereupon the record gets out of being stuck and continues on with
The way I do-o-o-....
He's also a stickler for detail, into vinyl and wants to know where on the record he should place the tonearm so that he can act like it's `sticking' in the groove and the revolutions will match.
If there's no revolution on a 12-inch record that's close enough to match, he's open to having the guy be a retired radio DJ and using a 16-inch record.
The scene he's shooting involves a depressed man who walks into his apartment and the Mama Cass record he started when he left earlier is still playing - and sticking in the groove.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSu_irpykNo
No-one else
Will ever love you
plays over and over and over until he shoots himself in the head - whereupon the record gets out of being stuck and continues on with
The way I do-o-o-....
He's also a stickler for detail, into vinyl and wants to know where on the record he should place the tonearm so that he can act like it's `sticking' in the groove and the revolutions will match.
If there's no revolution on a 12-inch record that's close enough to match, he's open to having the guy be a retired radio DJ and using a 16-inch record.
2 Kinds of Men/Records: Low Noise & Wide Range. LN is mod. fidelity, cheap, & easy. WR is High Fidelity & Abrasive to its' Environment. Remember that when you encounter a Grumpy Engineer. (:-D)
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
Hi,
Unless I'm missing something, it doesn't matter where on the record you are. One revolution at 33.33 RPM is 1.8 seconds, so the phrase would have to be exactly that long to repeat once each revolution. Just like a locked grove. If the phrase does not fit in this way, you would have to have the platter spin at a faster or slower speed to make it match the length of the phrase. I assume he would digitally create the skipping loop and decide in advance the number of repeats before allowing the tune to continue.
Mark
Unless I'm missing something, it doesn't matter where on the record you are. One revolution at 33.33 RPM is 1.8 seconds, so the phrase would have to be exactly that long to repeat once each revolution. Just like a locked grove. If the phrase does not fit in this way, you would have to have the platter spin at a faster or slower speed to make it match the length of the phrase. I assume he would digitally create the skipping loop and decide in advance the number of repeats before allowing the tune to continue.
Mark
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
I was just curious because in almost every instance I have ever seen a record skipping on a movie or TV show - the revolutions never match on a closeup.
I always thought the paths were longer near the edge of the record than in the center - but on a CAV system like an LP - you're right - that would only give an increase or decrease in fidelity rather than time as on a CLV system like on a CD. So 1.8 x2 would equal 3.6 - almost long enough - and just use 16 RPM.
I guess I was tired when I wrote that - cuz we were discussing fixed-pitch and variable-pitch and disc times for the various versions of each (96, 110, 135, 160 - very few LPs or 45's went beyond 160 in the classic vinyl days of the 50s and 60's - which is why they came up with variable pitch in the first place).markrob wrote:If the phrase does not fit in this way, you would have to have the platter spin at a faster or slower speed to make it match the length of the phrase.
I always thought the paths were longer near the edge of the record than in the center - but on a CAV system like an LP - you're right - that would only give an increase or decrease in fidelity rather than time as on a CLV system like on a CD. So 1.8 x2 would equal 3.6 - almost long enough - and just use 16 RPM.
Yep - including the thump from the record skipping - several of which are available on any number of sound effects CDs. Just drop one inbetween the loops and you got it.markrob wrote:I assume he would digitally create the skipping loop and decide in advance the number of repeats before allowing the tune to continue.
2 Kinds of Men/Records: Low Noise & Wide Range. LN is mod. fidelity, cheap, & easy. WR is High Fidelity & Abrasive to its' Environment. Remember that when you encounter a Grumpy Engineer. (:-D)
- Kiss the Groove
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Tue Jan 31, 2012 11:42 am
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
And he's not going to be bothered by seeing the disc spinning at half speed?He's also a stickler for detail, into vinyl ...
Just sayin'... KtG
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
Not if we use one of those specially-made Allied Artists 16-RPM records that got made all the way into the 80's for restaurants and malls who didn't want to go to tape or CD yet.Kiss the Groove wrote:And he's not going to be bothered by seeing the disc spinning at half speed?
I think you can count the collectors of those on two hands - none of whom has ever made a track list of any of those - which were produced a few per month for like 30 years - and contained any number of commercially-available music from all the major labels - and a few minor ones as well - so maybe like three old dork men in the US would know which track was on which album. Especially if we shoot it in such a way that the album number is not visible.
That's NOT counting the far more readily available ``regular'' Seeburg or Rowe or CustoMusic nine inch 16 RPM's with the two inch holes that contained proprietarily-recorded covers of all the hits of the day - which also were made from the mid 50's into the mid 80's
2 Kinds of Men/Records: Low Noise & Wide Range. LN is mod. fidelity, cheap, & easy. WR is High Fidelity & Abrasive to its' Environment. Remember that when you encounter a Grumpy Engineer. (:-D)
- Jesus H Chrysler
- Posts: 190
- Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2006 12:03 am
- Location: Asheville, NC
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
how about this for a solution: have it play" no one else will ever love you" and skip on "ever love you (pop) ever love you (pop) ever love you".....etc until (gunshot) "the way I do" I think it'd be pretty close to a 33 rpm skip and have the intended effect.
Re: One for All the Math Geniuses
Or `No one else ----will ever love you'' and skip backwards on ``no one else'---no one else----no one else... (GUNSHOT) and then skip OVER `will ever love you' and go on to `the way I doooo.'
Dunno which would have the better effect. We might film all three versions and see what works best on the screen. Sometimes you can't tell til you get it up on the wall thirty feet high what works and what don't.
Dunno which would have the better effect. We might film all three versions and see what works best on the screen. Sometimes you can't tell til you get it up on the wall thirty feet high what works and what don't.
2 Kinds of Men/Records: Low Noise & Wide Range. LN is mod. fidelity, cheap, & easy. WR is High Fidelity & Abrasive to its' Environment. Remember that when you encounter a Grumpy Engineer. (:-D)